: Suggestions thread
gearhead65 12-13-2009, 11:45 AM Feel free to suggest ways of making the G8 of the month contest better. A lot of forums have similar contests, but different rules. One suggestion submitted to me was nomination entries only. I like this idea. We may try this to see how this works out. Another forum's contest has a different theme every month (night photos, city backgrounds, etc.) Any other ideas?
gearhead65 01-04-2010, 10:03 AM No suggestions?? Really?
Rich-n-Texas 01-04-2010, 01:51 PM I suggest that photos that are photoshopped not be allowed. It's not natural and not everyone has access to that s/w. Maybe I'm missing something though. :dunno:
jaxredg8 01-04-2010, 04:12 PM Must admit I agree with the no photoshopping! And the other forums I'm on usually have an open invite and then starting later in the month start voting down to say 10, then 5 and then a winner. Any ideas are cool though!
1) Limit amount of g8's in final voting to 4 or 5. I think there were way too many in the 1st poll
2) Once a g8 wins g8 of the month, make it so they are not allowed to be nominated again until the following year. (because if there is a badass g8 on the board, everyone will keep nominating it and it will keep wining making it unfair for others)
But it's ok to be nominated more than once, unless you have already won.
that just makes it fair imo
gearhead65 01-06-2010, 09:08 AM New changes have been made.
How would you guys like it if maybe it was theme based? In this case, people would have to submit their own pics because it would be too difficult to nominate a pic based on the criteria, IMO. i.e, City background pics, night pics, etc. An issue I could see with this is that not everyone would have access to certain sceneries, conditions, etc. Just a thought.
Christiancoach 01-06-2010, 03:40 PM I would suggest not completely do away with Photoshopped images. Maybe make one month a No Photoshop, one month night shot, one month photoshopped, one month action shots. My 2 cents.
gearhead65 01-25-2010, 08:31 PM Alright, photoshopping is back in (at least for March). But, it's going to be themed. Any ideas for a theme?
hazer396 01-25-2010, 10:39 PM but ok i think there should be features.. like the best overall G8.. not the best pic...
like depending on Mods, Appearance, ETC. not just who has the best pic.. cuz alot of people dont have DSLR cameras or photoshops so this wont be equal!
SmokeyBear911 01-26-2010, 12:44 AM Maybe make rules and stick to them? lol...
purple_power 01-26-2010, 06:58 AM My suggestion is to maybe let some honorary G8s in..... say a VE Commodore? :D
gearhead65 01-26-2010, 09:48 AM My suggestion is to maybe let some honorary G8s in..... say a VE Commodore? :D
Yes, they are allowed already.
gearhead65 01-26-2010, 09:50 AM Maybe make rules and stick to them? lol...
Now how would that be any fun?
Rich-n-Texas 01-26-2010, 10:40 AM Maybe make rules and stick to them? lol...
Maybe make some helpful suggestions instead of useless cracks. Isn't this the "Suggestions Thread"? lol...
jaxredg8 01-26-2010, 04:32 PM ^ Yeah, what he said..... lol
purple_power 01-27-2010, 06:43 AM I'm thinking of bringing my car to the US next year. Will it count as a G8 then???
jaxredg8 01-27-2010, 06:01 PM ^ Always! Would be awesome to see! Where might you be bringing it to?
purple_power 01-28-2010, 05:50 AM Not entirely sure yet, but to the G8 rally, wherever that is. It's all just a maybe right now, but basically I'll start in L.A. then drive to Kentucky.....then hang around for a few weeks, then end up at the G8 rally. :)
Rich-n-Texas 02-15-2010, 10:40 AM I suggest, that for the April COTM, we go back to just individual shots of cars so anyone who hasn't entered their ride can do so without it needing to be an *in action* pose. Follow the K.I.S.S. rule.
gearhead65 02-15-2010, 08:54 PM We can do that. I was going to do a different theme each month, i.e., Beach/Ocean/River background, city background, night shots, etc. Not only action shots, that was just for this month only. But if that's what you guys want we can do regular shots. Doesn't matter to me. But, I think the cap will still apply so we don't have too many entries. The general consensus seems to agree that the first month's had way too many.
cryingspyder 03-31-2010, 05:21 PM How about we make one months theme, in front of a building that everyone has access to. Such as a gas station, school, hospital, etc....
Or we could even make it a little more difficult and have to take it with a....lets see...i know, a national monument. Like say...um....oh what could it be? Of course, yes " Devils Tower". I win I win. Yeah.
hazer396 04-08-2010, 12:29 PM you should instead of the front page of the site, add it into the site banner (where it says G8Board.com)
gearhead65 04-08-2010, 01:41 PM you should instead of the front page of the site, add it into the site banner (where it says G8Board.com)
I don't have control over that. That's an administrator accessible feature only.
Rich-n-Texas 04-08-2010, 01:57 PM Personally I don't like that idea. Most automotive discussion forums that I've been around that have a car of the month feature displayed it on the front page of the parent of the board. You'll notice that this discussion forum is only one aspect of AutoGuide; people who may not even care about message boards will still see the G8 of the month if it's on the top level page.
Christiancoach 04-12-2010, 02:21 PM I was thinking a good theme for one of the months could be, Best Photo at a Car Show/Event. Something with other cars in the background.
Rich-n-Texas 07-09-2010, 10:12 AM For Sept. I suggest the COTM should be of action shots at the drag strip, autocross or road course events. This is an aspect of our "performance sedans" that should be brought to the forefront once-in-a-while.
gearhead65 07-09-2010, 03:56 PM For Sept. I suggest the COTM should be of action shots at the drag strip, autocross or road course events. This is an aspect of our "performance sedans" that should be brought to the forefront once-in-a-while.
We did that a few months ago, but I suppose we could do it again. Or maybe another kind of theme.
jimmytt6 07-10-2010, 10:03 AM How about best engine picture?? Just a thought though doesn't really show whole car..
jaxredg8 07-10-2010, 01:31 PM How about bling??
Rich-n-Texas 07-12-2010, 01:58 PM We did that a few months ago, but I suppose we could do it again. Or maybe another kind of theme.
That was just an in general "Action Shots" contest. I'm thinking more in terms of shots of the G8 doing burnouts at the strip; into the turns at a famous road course, or maybe Jaysin knocking over some cones at an AutoX. ;)
300King 08-19-2010, 04:27 PM October's theme for G8OTM should be best photos from the national meet. Just a thought I had, although that would limit the number of potential participants. BUT it is only one month and might be a cool way to showcase the biggest G8 event to date.
purple_power 10-28-2010, 09:00 AM Why didn't I think of this earlier? How about a V6 month? There are a lot of comments that there hasn't been a V6 winner. If one month is open ONLY to V6's, one of them has to win!
Bad Karma 10-28-2010, 02:33 PM I like the way you think, Purple. You could even extrapolate that to include a GXP only month or something.
How about an Inside Your Engine Bay month?
gearhead65 10-28-2010, 03:14 PM Why didn't I think of this earlier? How about a V6 month? There are a lot of comments that there hasn't been a V6 winner. If one month is open ONLY to V6's, one of them has to win!
Well, kinda like the GXPs, but even less common are V6 entries. If we limited it to V6 only, we'd get 3-4 entries at best. Look how the theme went this month, very little entries, even though I know there are a lot more track pictures out there. Then again, I guess that's not something everyone can do either. We don't have any tracks around here so that excluded all my pictures as well.
gearhead65 10-28-2010, 03:18 PM I like the way you think, Purple. You could even extrapolate that to include a GXP only month or something.
How about an Inside Your Engine Bay month?
That might be doable since everyone can participate, even with a stock engine bay. It doesn't have to be a beautiful engine bay, just a beautiful shot of your engine bay. Hmmm...we can probably do this one for one of the months.
See this ->thread (http://www.g8board.com/forums/showthread.php?p=611856#post611856)<-
purple_power 10-29-2010, 11:06 PM Hmmmm, maybe we need a stick of dynamite under the V6 owners, to get them to enter.
You should have had a cut off date this month, so that those who got their entries in on time were the ones judged.
(I'm trying to think of some way I can win!!!)
steveo9043 11-02-2010, 09:55 AM I am new to the site and I haven't heard anyone mention this. I also noticed that it looked like G8OTM started January of this year? Or was last years deleted? Anyways, what about G8OTY (of the year) Take all 12 winners of G8OTM and pin them against each other.
I also noticed that not a lot of cars are getting more then a few votes each month. Why not do a preliminary round and set a min votes required to make it to the final round. If the min is 5 you take only the cars with 5 or more votes and do another round of voting with just those.
gearhead65 11-02-2010, 12:17 PM I am new to the site and I haven't heard anyone mention this. I also noticed that it looked like G8OTM started January of this year? Or was last years deleted? Anyways, what about G8OTY (of the year) Take all 12 winners of G8OTM and pin them against each other.
I also noticed that not a lot of cars are getting more then a few votes each month. Why not do a preliminary round and set a min votes required to make it to the final round. If the min is 5 you take only the cars with 5 or more votes and do another round of voting with just those.
That's exactly my intent! Should be interesting!
This is the first year of doing this, so there has been trial and error all year, but it seems to be going pretty smooth. Now if we could get some vendors to sponsor some prizes......:D
steveo9043 11-02-2010, 12:57 PM Does G8board.com have t-shirts/apparel? I think a good prize would be possibly a G8board.com t-shirt. Possibly yearly winner gets put on the T-shirts for next year?
tvr1204 12-27-2010, 02:56 PM I love all g8s, how about haveing a v6 along with a gt,gxp, or a firehawk, on each month? all colors are great too. I have the 2011 calendar, is there a 2010 g8 calendar? if so how can i get one?
jaxredg8 12-28-2010, 08:37 AM I still want a "Rival" photo contest. Like your G8 nose to nose with say a Mustang or Charger or doing a burnout in front of one of those cars. Just an idea. I think all these ideas sound pretty good!
KLR GOAT 12-28-2010, 09:19 AM I second the calendar idea. G8 of the year on the cover and all others on the month that they won.
steveo9043 12-28-2010, 10:04 AM KLR GOAT what rims are those on the GTO in ur sig? They look bad ass!
as for the GXP and V6 car of the month.... I dont know what the Trim of the G8 has to do with winning. It all seems to be based off the exterior appearance of the car. Yes the v6 gt gxp has small style changes between them but if you do exterior style mods to the car no one trim level has an advantage over another. Just my opinion.
KLR GOAT 12-28-2010, 10:59 AM KLR GOAT what rims are those on the GTO in ur sig? They look bad ass! Thanks...they are TSW Thruxtons. 18X8 up front and 18X9.5 out back.
Schwartz 12-28-2010, 10:35 PM I'm not sure exactly how many colors there are,but different colors for each month would be pretty cool.Or maybe pick 2 colors for each month,like one month you can have red & white another month have black & blue.Just a thought:wink2:.You could have a USA month,red white and blue only.
steveo9043 12-30-2010, 09:55 AM When does the theme for G8 oftm come out for january? I want to participate and need time to snap some pictures. Seeing as January is in 2 days I figured I'd ask
gearhead65 12-31-2010, 01:57 PM No theme for January. February might have one. I'll let you guys know.
The Yeti 02-17-2011, 09:21 PM I wouldn't mind seeing a G8 of the week deal where on the front page there was an owners spotlight where they can talk about there car and mods or whatever and post the picture of their choosing. Maybe have the Mods select a contributing forum member. It could be like an honorary thing to be chosen by the forum mods who see people putting in work by being active in the forums. Then turn G8 of the month into more of a photo of the month type of deal to showcase someones photog art work on the front page as well.
Schwartz 05-04-2011, 07:50 PM Seriously,
Best V6 of the month
Best GT of the month
Best GXP of the month
Make a time limit to enter your vehicle,like 10 days or something.If only 6 or 7 V6's enter after the time limit is up then let the voting begin.I know it would be nice to see a V6 take down a GT/GXP but it may never happen.
SLO 60 10-01-2011, 09:06 AM No photo shopping pictures, should only accept unmodified pictures. I thought this was about who could get the best shot, not who can change the looks of the picture the best...
gearhead65 10-01-2011, 07:08 PM No photo shopping pictures, should only accept unmodified pictures. I thought this was about who could get the best shot, not who can change the looks of the picture the best...
That would be very hard to moderate. Some pictures look photoshopped but are not and some that are photoshopped could pass as a real picture. That used to be the rule, but I'm no picture expert so I can't enforce that. But for those that have the reasoning that it leaves people out because they have expensive software, that's not true. You can download plenty of free software that will do most of the cool effects.
SLO 60 10-02-2011, 11:10 AM Still might not be a bad idea you could ask of people..
the_Gate 10-22-2011, 02:11 PM No photo shopping pictures, should only accept unmodified pictures. I thought this was about who could get the best shot, not who can change the looks of the picture the best...
i might be misunderstanding your circumstances behind when you can and cannot upload Photoshoped pics, but isnt it kinda handy to have people PS cosmetic things that your considering doing to your car? like powdercoating wheels, Firehawking the hood, blacking out tails.. that kinda thing
Boss Hogg 11-02-2011, 04:54 PM In addition to the V6, GT, & GXP of the month; how about an International version for our Aussie, Middle East, British friends?
Christiancoach 04-05-2012, 09:01 AM How about a month where it is all new people. All people who have not entered before. Call it the Rookie Challenge or something.
SLO 60 04-05-2012, 11:18 AM ^ Good idea!
stangkilr 04-19-2012, 11:56 AM i think we should do like the TBssowners forum does. Whoever wins gets their car in the header of the site. So instead of the red gxp up top on the left it could be that current months winner??
http://tbssowners.com/forums/index.php
Rich G 04-21-2012, 06:45 PM In addition to the V6, GT, & GXP of the month; how about an International version for our Aussie, Middle East, British friends?
I really likie that idea there are some real nice imports that don't get nearly enough credit on the site that should be rewarded for it...
VegasNate 04-23-2012, 10:43 AM I think the winner should get one million dollars......I bet participation/voting gets very high then.
gearhead65 04-29-2012, 04:38 PM i think we should do like the TBssowners forum does. Whoever wins gets their car in the header of the site. So instead of the red gxp up top on the left it could be that current months winner??
http://tbssowners.com/forums/index.php
That was suggested some time ago, but it was determined not feasible by the "higher ups".
|